The Week Wall Street Thanked Weak Economic Data

Key Takeaways

• Markets rallied despite weak economic data as investors revived the idea that “bad news is good news,” expecting the Federal Reserve to move toward easing.

• Soft consumer spending, fading confidence, and early signs of labor-market cooling strengthened the case for a potential December rate cut.

• Hopes for progress in Russia-Ukraine ceasefire talks drove oil prices sharply lower, reinforcing the broader disinflation narrative.

• Fed officials remain divided, with some warning that inflation near 3% could limit the pace of easing even if cuts begin soon.

• Geopolitical uncertainty and fragile economic signals mean the optimism that lifted markets this week could prove temporary.

---

The holiday-shortened week delivered an ironic twist: markets rallied on a steady stream of disappointing economic data. Investors leaned back into the old “bad news is good news” mindset, interpreting soft consumer spending, fading confidence, and weaker labor trends as evidence that the Federal Reserve may finally shift toward easing. By the time markets closed early on Black Friday, major equity indexes had logged their strongest week since June.² Stocks climbed even as long-term Treasury yields slipped, suggesting investors were preparing for monetary relief rather than worrying about the slowdown itself.¹ Weakness, in other words, became a source of optimism.

Dovish Data and the Return of the Fed Pivot Narrative

Much of the week’s enthusiasm stemmed from a simple narrative: the economy is cooling just enough to justify a rate cut. Retail sales barely advanced, undershooting expectations, and consumer confidence slumped to its lowest reading in months.¹ Unemployment has edged higher, and the labor market—once the brightest part of the economic backdrop—is showing signs of fatigue.¹

Federal Reserve officials, who spent most of the year warning about sticky inflation, sounded noticeably less concerned. Governor Christopher Waller remarked that the labor market now appears “weak enough” to support a December cut.³ San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly echoed the sentiment, and New York Fed President John Williams suggested cuts could occur “in the near term” without undermining progress on inflation.³ Their remarks hit just as the data softened, giving investors a strong reason to believe easing was close.

Futures markets responded quickly. Within days, traders were pricing in a high probability of a quarter-point reduction at the December 10 meeting.¹ That shift helped pull bond yields lower and powered an equity rally that stretched across sectors.

Not all Fed officials were convinced. Some expressed concern that inflation—while much lower than last year—remains above target and cautioned against easing prematurely.³ Abroad, the European Central Bank maintained its patient posture as eurozone inflation held near 2.1%.⁴ Meanwhile, the Bank of Japan surprised markets by continuing to prepare for a potential rate hike after decades of ultra-easy policy.¹